Showing posts with label comics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label comics. Show all posts

Monday, August 24, 2009

The Many Letters of Todd Klein

Hey, I got my scanner working!

1993, Sandman #41

And since I'm still waiting for the 2009 Hugo winners to show up in my mailbox it's time for the Eisner award winning work of Todd Klein.

Klein has won more often than anyone; since 1993 there have been only two years where he has not won an Eisner award. Klein has lettered some of the best comics published which doesn't hurt when it comes to fan recognition but even without that he's got a good sense of design.

So here is a sampling of his work from each of the years which he won an Eisner for.

1994, Hellblazer #67

1995, Sandman #62

1997, Kingdom Come #3

1998, Castle Waiting: The Curse of Brambly Hedge

1999, Castle Waiting #5

2000, Tom Strong #4

2001, Top Ten #9

2002, Tom Strong's Terrific Tales #1

2003, Fables #6

2004, 1602 #2

2005, Fables #25

2006, Seven Soldiers #0

2007, Eternals #3

2008, Crossing Midnight #6

Monday, June 22, 2009

Damn it


This copy is going back too...

Thursday, May 28, 2009

2009 Hugo Nominees - Best Graphic Story

First, here's another nominee for best professional artist, Donato Giancola:

The nominees for the new best graphic story category are interesting since they can be easily broken into three blocks of two books. We have two licensed comics based on already popular SF properties, two climaxes to long running Vertigo series, and two webcomics. I don't usually read licensed comics since they usually disappoint so those were the two I had not read before. The two webcomic nominees are one third of all the webcomics I follow and of the remaining webcomics there's only one that might even be considdered for the award. So I'm going to break it down by those blocks.

The Dresden Files: Welcome to the Jungle; written by Jim Butcher; art by Ardian Syaf - Though I'm aware of Butcher's novel series about a hard boiled wizard detective in modern Chicago I haven't read any of them. The books have been recommended to me a few times but I'm always hesitant to pick up any book that's described as part of a "series". After reading this comic series I think I will try one of the novels. This comic had the advantage of being written by Butcher and unlike some writers from other mediums Butcher used the comic format well; his dialog is tight and complements the images. In this story the wizard/detective is called in to consult on a murder at a zoo that is being blamed on a gorrilla. Naturally there's evil magic involved and the detective gets in over his head. I don't want to discount Syaf's contribution to this work; most memorably he drew the title character in an overshadowed hard-boiled rough style while his unwilling sidekick is much lighter. The whole thing made for a charming book that made me smile.

Serenity: Better Days; written by Joss Whedon and Brett Matthews; art by Will Conrad; color by Michelle Madsen; cover by Jo Chen - In contrast with the previous book this is exactly why I don't read licensed comic books. While all of the common beats from the Firefly television series are here this comic is like a faded photocopy. The scruffy rogue characters are there but they're a bit off. It's a plot that you might see in the show (the crew makes a large pile of money while they're being hunted by someone looking for veterans of the war) but it doesn't come across well. There are moments that are effective and they are fleeting. The main storyline is disjointed and jumps from big moment to big moment. Given how the dialog just falls flat I strongly suspect that Whedon's involvement with this comic was just to say "Hey, let's make a Firefly comic!" and putting his name on it to increase sales. Conrad's art isn't bad but is nowhere near smooth enough to make up for that story.

Y: The Last Man, Volume 10: Whys and Wherefores; written by Brian K. Vaughan; pencilled by Pia Guerra; inked by Jose Marzan, Jr. - I never thought I would enjoy a series about all the male mammels on earth dying except one man and his monkey. Instead of taking the obvious route Vaughan turned it into a journey into a post-apocalyptic world as the last man wandered the face of the earth looking for the girlfriend he was about to propose to over the phone when the deaths struck. In this last volume he finally catches up with her after years of wandering and has to decide what he really wants. Simultaniously his enemies are catching up with him for one last confrontation. That storyline is incredibly effective as Vaughn and Guerra capture the growth that all the characters have undergone. The final issue is a bit more controversial since it jumps forward several decades and is filled with a lot of clumsy dialog telling the readers what happened to everyone. On the other hand the conclusion of that final issue is absolutely perfect. Still this is a very good story that only suffers because the reader needs to have read the rest of the series to appreciate it.

Fables: War and Pieces; written by Bill Willingham; pencilled by Mark Buckingham; art by Steve Leialoha and Andrew Pepoy; color by Lee Loughridge; letters by Todd Klein - I'm a bit confused on this nominee: there's a three issue storyline titled "War and Pieces" that's part of the Fables series and there's a six issue trade paperback War and Pieces. Given the context of the nominees I believe that they mean the trade paperback but I can't be certain. The series itself is about all stories being true (especially fairy tales) on other planes of existence. Before the series began one of the characters, known only as the Adversary now, has conquored all of the other worlds forcing the characters in those fairy tales to flee to the real world. In this volume those refugees take the lessons of the real world back to make war on the Adversary. So there is a spy story as one gathers vital information which is followed by the story of the very brief and very brutal war. This volume does have the advantage of standing well on its own though again as the climax of a seventy-five issue long storyline it's more effective if the reader doesn't start at the end. Willingham clearly planned out the war carefully which makes the plan something simple and direct that the reader can both understand and believe. Buckingham always does a great job and for the final issue in the storyline does everything in spectacular verticle layouts.

Girl Genius, Volume 8: Agatha Heterodyne and the Chapel of Bones; written by Kaja and Phil Foglio; art by Phil Foglio; colors by Cheyenne Wright - The premise of this webcomic is a psuedo-Victorian world where some people possess the ability to create steampunk inventions that break the laws of physics. Agatha Heterodyne is the heir to the greatest family of mad scientists and has been in hiding her whole life from the forces that tore her family apart. In this section of the story she has returned to her ancestral home, an intelligent castle that has gone insane in her absense. People who want to seize that power for themselves or destroy it before it can be used have also arrived and Agatha must attempt to gain control over the castle before their plans can be activated. I've enjoyed the Foglio's work since I saw it in Dragon magazine and the webcomic is up to their standards. Unfortunately this particular storyline feels more like a bridge between larger events than a contained story of its own. We have a lot of characters moving to get into position to react but very little of them actually taking action.

Schlock Mercenary: The Body Politic; by Howard Tayler - In contrast this storyline is almost completely self-contained. The mercenary crew that stars in this strip sold one of their enemies to some revolutionaries in a desperate situation as a "military aide". That enemy managed to win the revolution and install himself as king of the planet though his reign is measured in hours. Now the mercenaries find themselves in a classic dilema: they have two people who hire them to steal the body and the government of the planet hires them to guard the body. The dilema, of course, is how can they get paid three times for the same work. Tayler's art isn't up to the quality of the other nominees (he's grown from a doodler in his first few strips to a decent cartoonist over the ten years he's been working on the strip); still the actual story is among the best thanks to it's snappy pacing as a daily comic strip. Tayler keeps things moving from gag to gag and also recognizing that any given strip could be someone's first and that makes it very accessable.

My ballot for Best Graphic Story would be:

The Dresden Files
Schlock Mercenary

Fables

Y: The Last Man
Girl Genius

No Award
Serenity

Friday, January 2, 2009

Watchmen in Thirty Seconds

The Invincible Super-Blog's anniversary has rolled around again and once more he has invited any comic fan with no shame to quickly recap a comic story. Last year I did the entire history of the DC Universe. This year I thought I would go for it: the sacred cow of comic books, Watchmen.

And why shouldn't I? Works considered to be classic literature are far from immune to parody (Shakespearean parodies alone could keep an infinite number of monkeys tied up for a bit) and Watchmen is one of two comics that fall directly under my mission of reading all of the award winning fantasy and SF.

Of course Chris over at The Invincible Super-Blog beat me to it.

Still I think there's enough room in this world for two people having a bit of fun with Watchmen.

(Click on the pictures to make them nice and readable...)


Tuesday, December 23, 2008

Christmas Week - Part 2

Why the Hulk doesn't get to play Santa at the Marvel Christmas party anymore:


(Reviews to continue after I don't have to worry about falling behind on my reading due to holiday activities. Besides I haven't done a lot of comics stuff lately since I've almost exclusively been catching up on about 10,000 pages of Lone Wolf and Cub and Usagi Yojimbo. Sadly that page count is not an exageration.)

Monday, December 22, 2008

Christmas Week - Part 1

Question: how do you retheme your existing art for Christmas?


Answer: Draw holly over the existing lines.

Thursday, October 16, 2008

Review - Schlock Mercenary: The Teraport Wars

I don't read a whole lot of webcomics. I used to back in the young days of the web when the idea that someone might draw a comic and put it on the web was a wild idea. Those early pioneers set patterns still seen today: the wanna-be epic where a humor strip loses humor for massive infodumps of bad story requiring understanding of years of confusing continuity, the fanbase pandering where in-jokes take over, the egotrips where self aggrandizement takes the place of actually making the comic, and more. There are acres of webcomics where the artistic quality of the first strip is as good as it ever gets no matter how terrible it is. And that doesn't even get into the massive piles of strips that are just outright terrible.

One of the very few I do read consistantly is Schlock Mercenary which I've been following for more than seven years. The ongoing story of mercenaries a thousand years into a space opera future manages to hold me for three key reasons and they all are in the writing: it's clearly told, well paced, and strip creator Howard Taylor makes a point of recognizing the ugly consequences of the details of his world. Taylor has just released his fourth print collection of strips entitled The Teraport Wars which cover nearly eighteen months of his daily strip.

There's a lot of stories in The Teraport Wars but its central one is a conflict between a fleet of altruists and dyson sphere building aliens who have manipulated interstellar civilization for over a hundred thousand years by torturing secrets out of anyone who used their interstellar transportation system with the mercenary cast stuck in the middle and just wanting to get paid.

This is the best value of any web comic strip collection I've ever seen.

Strike that: this is the second best value of any comic strip colection I've ever seen beaten only by those really impressive Fantagraphics collections and they only edge this out by being the complete works of various masters of the art form. First, The Teraport Wars is more than 210 pages of strips for twenty-five dollars. That's 493 daily strips. You'll pay only slightly less than that for half the content from most people. Second the production values are exceptional. It's printed on glossy paper in full color with a layout that flows smoothly and allows plenty of room for notes from the author and sketches.

And the content isn't bad either. Taylor moves quickly from story arc to story arc and there's a lot of big space opera action. The cast is a wondeful collection of barely functional sociopaths who have taken the saying "Violence is the last resort of the incompetent" to heart; they're not incompetent so they resort to violence much earlier.

One stumbling block is the art. In the beginning the art in Schlock Mercenary was... well... terrible. I've seen worse art in webcomics but not often. By the start of The Teraport Wars Taylor was on his way to developing his ability but things were still rough. By the end of the book you can see real development in the art (eventually he does drop the thick inking). Taylor aknowledges this; in fact the first collection of his strips actually follows The Teraport Wars for when they were originally published.

Webcomic collections can be a tough sell since who needs a print collection of what's being given away on the web? The Teraport Wars does deliver on that by being a wonderful presentation of the strips. if you haven't read Schlock Mercenary I'd say jump to the beginning of the current storyline where the band of thugs takes on a mission of mercy where everyone is in over their heads.

Tuesday, September 30, 2008

Short Review - The Umbrella Academy


A lot of comic book fans online have recommended The Umbrella Academy so I finally got around to reading it the other day. I can see what people like; it is an exciting cacophony of psychedelic imagery. Unfortunately there's nothing else to it and so I was left disappointed that so many interesting ideas were tinkered with and then forgotten.

There was a group of children with special powers who had mad cap adventures. As they grew up, though, they came to despise their adopted father and went their separate ways. When their father dies they reunite only to be informed by their time traveling sibling that the end of the world is coming.

As I said, the imagery is interesting. The book opens with a wrestler defeating a cosmic squid and potentially causing the virgin births of dozens of superpowered children around the world. This leads directly into the Eiffel Tower being piloted by a steam powered zombie robot Gustav Eiffel rampaging in Paris before launching itself into space. This is the kind of thing that happens constantly in the book with little rhyme or reason for it. That can work if the reader has some kind of anchor elsewhere, a plot or characters to connect them to the insanity. Writer Gerald Way attempts to do this and fails miserably.

There's two storylines that he attempts to pursue. The first is the end of the world driven by an evil orchestra that one of the siblings joins. This is driven by random events with no context and the resolution of every aspect to it is a deus ex machina where something new comes in from left field or someone demonstrates an ability the reader was never informed they had. The reader is supposed to react to how cool the events are but I was left wondering why I should care.

The other story, and the one that it seems like the book is really trying to hook onto, is the siblings dealing with the death of their hated father. The problem here is that we just don't know enough about any of them or their relationships. What little is in the pages of The Umbrella Academy is hamhanded (the father telling one of them "You're just not special," early on in the story for example).

The impression that I got is that I was supposed to know who all of these characters were before I read the book by reading exposition that was not provided in the story (and as someone who hates giant blocks of exposition it kills me to say that the story did not have enough). I typically didn't work out even the basics of who the characters were until it was far too late. An example of this is that one of the character's special powers is vital to the way the other characters treat them but the reader is never told what their power is until a story that is printed in the book after the miniseries. She uses her ability once in the first few pages in a very ambiguous method and apparently Way thought that was sufficient to establish everything the reader needed to know.

That's a problem for the whole series: far too much is ambiguous. Not just the little story developments or character twists but fundimental information that the reader needs to comprehend what is occurring. It was four issues in before I realized one of the characters had a human head on the body of a gorilla (I thought it was his space suit until that point). And I'm still not sure how everyone put together enough information to show up for the climax of the story.

The Umbrella Academy depends on the reader reacting to the events and ignoring them in the context of the whole and I'm just not capable of doing that. When I was younger I might have been distracted by the shiney moments and then accepted its flaws. I am not that young anymore, however, and so I can't recommend it.

Monday, September 15, 2008

Batman's Nunchuck Collection

I've been relaxing since finishing off my reviews of all of the Nebula winning novels but then this comes along.

(By the way, don't expect a lot of book reviews until I feel up to tackling the World Fantasy Awards and that may be a few months.)

Chris Sims of The Invincible Super Blog provided the world with the concept of Batman with Shark Nunchucks. Others took up the torch and gave us more options for things that Batman could tie together and beat people with. Now the challenge has gone out for anyone regardless of artistic talent to do the same.

So I thought to myself, "Batman is always prepared. What nunchucks would let him be always prepared?" The answer when it occurred to me was obvious. Batman might be prepared for anything but there is only one person who has actually dealt with everything. So I give you...

Batman's Collection of Jimmy OlsenChucks!
(Click to Giant Turtle size it)

For those that need a score card that's Giant Turtle Olsen, Future Brain Olsen, Fat Alien Olsen, Werewolf Olsen, Elastic Lad, Porcupine Olsen, Bizarro Olsen, and just Jimmy Olsen. Oh and Batman being smug in the knowledge that he's prepared for anything.

I had a few more I considdered using but I stuck to just ones in the recent collection The Amazing Transformations of Jimmy Olsen just in case this inspires someone like a crazy cover off a spinner rack.

I can't wait to see what other people come up with...

Tuesday, September 2, 2008

Oddest Product Announcement... or Greatest?

Google announced their new web browser Chrome by sending out a thirty-eight page comic book by Scott "Understanding Comics" McCloud. Since everyone loves a Scott McCloud comic they've made the announcement available on their site.

I haven't tried the browser yet since I'm reasonably happy with Firefox and the list of new features hasn't made me jump for joy (I'm unconvinced that the performance will be significantly better for one). I'm holding off until the early adopters hit it and find the troubles.

Thursday, August 28, 2008

The King's Birthday

August 28th is the most important holiday on a comic fan's calendar: Jack Kirby's birthday. To celebrate, here is the first appearance of one of his greatest creations the Mighty Thorr:



Friday, August 8, 2008

Herbie Unleashed

We are nearing the release of the Herbie Archives and Herbiemania is growing! What? You don't know him? He's Alan Moore's favorite superhero:



Herbie is incredible where ever he goes. Here is in a page from The Bride of Hembeck (taken from the recent The Nearly Complete Essential Hembeck Archives Omnibus) where Herbie beats up western anti-hero Jonah Hex and steals Betty and Veronica away from Archie:

Thursday, July 31, 2008

Watchmania

Continuing Mars Week I give you the location of one of scenes in the upcoming movie Watchmen:

Much like the more famous "face" on the Cydonia plain this face is a trick of perspective. Still I bet the guys checking the returning images cracked up when they got that one back.

And looking at the current Amazon top ten best sellers list I see:



While I expected an upswing in interest in Watchmen as the movie approached I think every comic book nerd on earth is shocked at the response. A set of issues #1 to #12 are going for hundreds of dollars this week when a few months ago you'd be lucky to get twenty bucks for the set. Copies of the hardcover absolute edition (which is the version I currently own) are going for similar amounts despite the fact that DC plans to reissue it in a few months for the Christmas season. Retailers literally cannot keep the trade paperback on the shelf; many of them report that it sells almost as quickly as they put it out.

This is unprecedented in the history of comic book movies. Earlier comic book films might have caused an upswing in interest in the source material but not this frenzy. The Dark Knight has made Batman books get a bit more attention from comic book fans but it's not driving massive sales for The Dark Knight Returns. I don't know what else to say but "Good for Moore and Gibbons!" They deserve it even if I can't figure out why it's happening.

Saturday, July 26, 2008

"I knew you liked comics..."

"... so I got you these!"



Sigh.

Tuesday, July 22, 2008

The Far Side of the Gender Politics Loony Bin

After that Tehanu review I'm going to take a few moments to give equal time to other lunatic fringe in gender politics. Though less noisy than the distaff lunatic fringe their masculine counterparts are no less loony. And despite what you may think this isn't going to be about someone who wants to keep women barefoot and pregnant in the kitchen or even a religious fundamentalist (pick your least favorite religion to fill in that blank).

I'm going to tell you a bit about Dave Sim. Not an awful lot since I wanted to do a whole set of stories on his gradual descent into madness and I still might in the future, but I wanted to give you an idea.

First let me give you an idea of why anyone would know who Dave Sim was to begin with and why anyone would pay attention to him. He is the creator of Cerebus, perhaps the most ambitious comic book project ever conceived. While the title started as a parody of Barry Winsor-Smith's Conan comics (thus two firm steps removed from Howard) it quickly metamorphized into a more philosophical book with a light touch wrapped heavily in the religion and politics of their medieval world. Sim decided that the comic would run for exactly 300 issues telling the story of its title character and conclude with that character's death. He conceived its ongoing story in vast movements of more than twenty issues each and he did this in the mid-seventies when such long term planning were just a twinkles in British comic writers' eyes.

In the 1980's he became one of the most outspoken political voices in the comic book world commenting on the industry, working to encourage self-published comic books, and rallying people for causes like defending obscenity charges against comic shop owners. He turned his company into a showcase for independent comic books and was generally a very popular person in industry circles.

And then came the madness.

There were hints of it before. It was not so blatant that the masses would say, "Aha! Misogyny! Shun him!" instead of looking it as an unusual direction to take his story but in retrospect it is the first signs. The title character raped a woman and it was treated lightly. That did set some people off but by the end of that story arc he's lost everything and learned that he will die miserable so some punishment was coming. That same story arc let readers know that the male aspect of the universe was the creative one. Those warning signs were followed up by stories that detailed the hard choices in a woman's life and a retelling of the death of Oscar Wilde which dispersed the concerns.

The real change over came in the early 90's. In the middle of a storyline about a matriarchy taking over the world due to the fact that all women are mind controllers who force men to do their bidding (start inserting "Really!"'s here) Sim went into a tangent about the comics publishing industry. One of these lengthy essays printed as part of the comic story (as opposed to an editorial printed outside of it) took the cosmic male creative force and female devourer and put it at a human level. It was essentially "Women are all inherently evil trying to tear down men!" Sound familiar?

Sim rapidly lost the support he built up over the years and his rants in his comic became angrier and stranger. He turned his anger against anything he perceived as feminism and you can read at least one of his rants at The Dave Sim Misogyny Page.

He did eventually finish his 300 issue long story and someday I might actually finish it and then go through each volume here. I just want to buy the books used so Dave Sim won't get any more money from me.

Tuesday, July 1, 2008

A Late Review of Final Crisis 2


Now let's see if they can keep it up for seven issues...

Monday, June 23, 2008

Some Silly Filler

I'm leaving tomorrow and busy with preparations so here's some Spore creatures I've made:


And here's an image of the fine scanning work done by Google that I found while double checking my memory on a portion of Hamlet (yeah, I have multiple copies of the complete text of Shakespeare but sometimes Google is faster):



Finally to round things out here's the cover of the issue of Jimmy Olsen before Jack Kirby took over and started the Fourth World stories:


And the cover immediately after he left prematurely ending it:


Sadly he didn't have much of an impact, did he?

Tuesday, June 10, 2008

Finally

Finally after six weeks I have a copy of The Book of the New Sun so Nebula reviews will start again next week (just in time for me to go on vacation the week following). And since I'm already digging into it here's a picture of Captain America jumping off a motorcycle into a pack of gun toting neo-Nazis: